
Vascular Care, Dizziness and Tinnitus: Which to choose? A comprehensive analysis
As we age, many people begin to experience symptoms of poor peripheral circulation: cold hands and feet, memory decline, and even bothersome dizziness and tinnitus. When seeking solutions, "German Ginkgo" is often the first choice.
The two most common German brands on the market are "Tebonin" and "Hevert". Many people ask: "What's the difference between these two? Which one should I take for my symptoms?"
This article will delve into the differences between these two products in terms of vascular care, dizziness, and tinnitus from a pharmaceutical perspective, helping everyone to better understand the products and make smart choices.
________________________________________
Core Basis: Why Ginkgo Biloba Extract?
Before comparing, we must first understand their common core—Ginkgo Biloba.
The main pharmacological mechanisms of high-quality Ginkgo Biloba extract (not directly eating Ginkgo Biloba leaves or nuts) are:
1. Improves microcirculation: Increases the deformability of red blood cells and reduces blood viscosity, making blood flow more easily through tiny capillaries (especially in the brain and inner ear).
2. Antioxidant and neuroprotective: Scavenges free radicals and protects nerve cells from oxidative stress damage.
3. Regulates vascular tension: Helps blood vessels to dilate appropriately.
It is these mechanisms that make Ginkgo products a popular choice for improving cerebral and peripheral circulatory disorders.
________________________________________
Competitor 1: Tebonin – The Benchmark of Clinical Evidence
Tebonin is produced by the German pharmaceutical company Dr. Willmar Schwabe, and it is the most thoroughly researched Ginkgo product worldwide.
Core Advantage: Patented Extract EGb 761®
Tebonin's biggest selling point is that it uses not just ordinary Ginkgo extract, but the patented EGb 761®.
• Highly Standardized: EGb 761® undergoes more than 20 processes to strictly control the proportion of active ingredients (such as ginkgo flavone glycosides 24%, terpene lactones 6%) and removes harmful ginkgolic acids to below 5 parts per million (<5 ppm), ensuring safety for long-term use.
• Rich Clinical Evidence: Hundreds of clinical studies on EGb 761® worldwide have confirmed its efficacy in improving cerebral insufficiency (memory decline, poor concentration), dizziness, tinnitus, and peripheral arterial occlusive disease (such as intermittent claudication).
• Medical-grade Positioning: In Taiwan and many other countries, Tebonin (at specific dosages) is classified as an "over-the-counter drug" or a prescription drug, meaning its efficacy and safety are strictly reviewed by medical regulations, often making it the preferred choice for physicians.
________________________________________
Competitor 2: Hevert – The Natural Homeopathic Choice
Hevert is a renowned German natural medicine company, and its product line often combines herbal medicine with the concept of Homeopathy.
Core Advantage: Gentle and Holistic Conditioning
Hevert's Ginkgo products (there are many items on the market, specific specifications need to be confirmed) are usually positioned differently from Tebonin.
• Formula Differences: Some of Hevert's Ginkgo products are "homeopathic preparations" (for example, marked with dilution levels like D2, D4). The concept is not to rely on high-dose active ingredients for direct action, but to stimulate the body's self-healing ability through micro-stimulation. Some are also herbal extracts, but usually do not specifically emphasize a strict single standardization process like EGb 761.
• Gentle Positioning: Due to the dosage or mechanism of action, Hevert is often considered a gentler choice for health maintenance, suitable for individuals who are sensitive to medications or prefer natural and holistic therapies.
• Health Supplement Positioning: In most markets, Hevert's products are more classified as health supplements or homeopathic remedies, rather than first-line therapeutic drugs.
Super Comparison
|
Item |
Tebonin |
Hevert Ginkgo Series |
|
Manufacturer/Origin |
Dr. Willmar Schwabe, Germany |
Hevert-Arzneimittel, Germany |
|
Core Ingredient |
Patented EGb 761® standardized extract |
General Ginkgo Biloba leaf extract or Homeopathic formula |
|
Ingredient Consistency |
Extremely high (consistent active ingredients per batch) |
Varies depending on the specific product line |
|
Ginkgolic Acid Removal |
Strictly removed (<5 ppm) |
Depends on product specifications |
|
Clinical Evidence Level |
Extremely high (supported by hundreds of clinical trials worldwide) |
Lower (mainly based on traditional use experience or homeopathic theories) |
|
Taiwan Positioning |
Classified as OTC or prescription drug depending on dosage |
Mostly health supplements or imported goods |
|
Main Benefits |
Treats symptoms of cerebral and peripheral circulatory disorders |
Auxiliary maintenance, gentle conditioning |
|
Price Range |
Higher |
Relatively affordable (varies by channel) |
How to choose: Based on your symptoms?
1. Vascular Care (Cold hands and feet, peripheral numbness)
• Tebonin: If you have been diagnosed with early symptoms of peripheral arterial disease (such as leg fatigue when walking, intermittent claudication), or peripheral circulation problems caused by diabetes, Tebonin's highly concentrated standardized ingredients can provide stronger vasodilation and blood flow improvement, making it the medical preferred choice.
• Hevert: If you simply experience cold hands and feet in winter without underlying diseases and are looking for gentle daily maintenance, Hevert can be an introductory option.
2. Dizziness and Tinnitus (Related to cerebral circulation)
• Tebonin: For tinnitus (usually a high-pitched ringing sound) and sudden dizziness caused by "insufficient cerebral blood circulation" or "inner ear microcirculation disorders," EGb 761® has extensive clinical data supporting its improvement effects. Many ENT or neurology doctors recommend Tebonin as an auxiliary treatment.
• Hevert: For mild, occasional dizziness, or for those who wish to regulate their overall constitution with homeopathic remedies, Hevert is an option. However, if symptoms severely impact daily life, it is still recommended to prioritize products with stronger evidence-based medicine.
3. Memory Decline and Concentration
• Tebonin: For improving age-associated memory impairment in older adults, long-term use of standard doses of EGb 761® has been shown to help maintain cerebral oxygen supply and slow down decline.
________________________________________
Key Considerations and Contraindications
Regardless of which one you choose, Ginkgo products have common contraindications that must be followed:
1. Anticoagulant interaction: Ginkgo has an inhibitory effect on platelet aggregation. If you are taking anticoagulants (such as Warfarin, aspirin, Plavix, etc.), you must consult your doctor first to avoid increasing the risk of bleeding.
2. Discontinue before surgery: Ginkgo products should be stopped at least one week before scheduled surgery or tooth extraction.
3. Pregnancy and lactation: Not recommended.
4. Individual constitution: A very small number of people may experience gastrointestinal discomfort, headache, or skin allergic reactions after taking it.
________________________________________
Choose Your Vascular Protector Rationally
In this German Ginkgo showdown, there's no absolute winner; the key lies in your needs and health condition:
• If you are seeking "medical-grade evidence-based efficacy" to improve clear symptoms of dizziness, tinnitus, or circulatory disorders, and demand absolutely stable and safe quality, then Tebonin is the undeniable choice, representing the gold standard of Ginkgo pharmaceutical craftsmanship.
• If you are seeking "natural and gentle maintenance" for mild symptoms, tend towards homeopathic remedies, or have budget considerations, then Hevert offers another reliable German-made option.
Friendly Reminder: The causes of dizziness and tinnitus are complex and may involve ear, nerve, or even tumor problems. Before taking Ginkgo products on your own, it is strongly recommended to undergo a detailed examination at an ENT or neurology department to rule out serious underlying conditions and consult a medical professional for advice.
(Disclaimer: The information in this article is for educational purposes only and cannot replace professional medical diagnosis and treatment. Please consult a doctor or pharmacist before taking any medication.)



